Preparing for conclave, Cardinal Dolan visits his Rome parish


Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan speaks with journalists March 10 outside the Church of Our Lady of Guadalupe in Rome. (CNS/Paul Haring)

ROME (CNS) – An ordinary parish in a middle-class Rome neighborhood became a center of pre-conclave excitement March 10 when its honorary pastor, New York Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan, came to celebrate Sunday Mass.

Cardinal Dolan had taken formal possession of his titular church, Our Lady of Guadalupe, only five months earlier. Now he was back, two days before the start of voting in a papal election that some observers have said could end by making him the first American pope.

Entering at the end of a procession of two dozen priests and altar servers, the cardinal took five minutes to make his way up the aisle of the small church, stopping to greet individual parishioners as a trumpeter and organist played the baroque “Prince of Denmark’s March,” a standard of wedding ceremonies.

“What a big crowd,” Cardinal Dolan remarked during his homily, looking out at the standing-room-only congregation of more than 300, which included a number of journalists. “Let’s take two collections this morning, okay?”

He asked the parishioners to keep the “secret” that, “after St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York, this is my favorite church.”

“It is as a pastor of a parish in Rome, even if only honorary, that I am here to elect a new Bishop of Rome, a new pope,” he said. “We cardinals feel the support of the prayers of God’s people all over the world. This also makes us rejoice.”

Having smiled broadly through much of the liturgy, the cardinal assumed a solemn expression toward the end, when the trumpeter played a mournful solo resembling “Taps.” Msgr. Franco Mammoli, the church’s pastor, explained that the interlude was supposed to be a moment of prayer to the Holy Spirit for the cardinals who would be voting for the next pope.

Cardinal Dolan closed on a note of levity, however, joking that he might take some candies with him into the conclave, “because I’ve heard that the food isn’t good.”

He also said he hoped to visit the parish again before leaving Rome, since he would be staying until the installation Mass of the new pope. At that point, Msgr. Mammoli moved aside the microphone and told the cardinal something inaudible to the rest of the congregation.

Cardinal Dolan “seems like someone who knows how to speak to people, who knows how to stimulate each person’s soul,” said one parishioner, Germano Tatafiore, 52. “He touches you. He has a face, a voice, a manner that touch you.”

Italians would welcome the American as pope, Tatafiore said, among other reasons because he seems like someone who could end reported mismanagement and corruption inside the Vatican.

“He is a very sweet person, very open,” said another parishioner, Lina Napolitano. “Easygoing, very simple, even though he is a very smart person.”

After changing out of his vestments, the cardinal stepped to a window of the rectory to acknowledge a group of 30 American pilgrims led by the Sirius Radio host Lino Rulli. The pilgrims greeted him with shouts of “Pope Dolan!”

The cardinal stopped before leaving to speak briefly with several dozen journalists, largely from New York, whom he told that the cardinals’ pre-conclave meetings had left him with a feeing of “immense serenity.”

“The last week has been just filled with apostolic fraternity and good prayer and solid conversation, a real sense of trust and confidence,” he said. “A week ago we would have said, ‘wow, we’ve got a lot of work to do,’ but now you see a sense of resignation and trust and faith.”

Twelve to watch as cardinals gather in Rome

UPDATES: Here are more names we’ve added to our list of influential cardinals after we published the article below:

— Boston prelate known for humility, humor, crisis management (Cardinal Sean P. O’Malley)

— Italian cardinal sees holiness, prayer as key to vocations (Cardinal Mauro Piacenza)

— Pastor, educator: Genoa’s Cardinal Bagnasco promotes traditional family (Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco)

— Argentine Cardinal Bergoglio was second on each ballot in last conclave (Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio)


(Originally posted on

Editor’s Note: For more on each cardinal, click on the boldface links below.

By Cindy Wooden and Francis X. Rocca
Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — Wherever journalists and bookmakers may be getting the names on their lists of top candidates for the next pope, it’s not from the cardinals who will actually vote in the election. Both custom and canon law forbid the cardinals to discuss the matter in such detail with outsiders.

Moreover, the true “papabili” — literally, pope-ables — were likely to emerge only after all the worlds’ cardinals began their pre-conclave meetings at the Vatican last week.

One thing is already clear, however: because of their experience and the esteem they enjoy among their peers, certain cardinals are likely to serve as trusted advisers to the rest in the discussions and election.

Here, in alphabetical order, are 12 cardinals expected to have a major voice in the deliberations:

Cardinal Dolan arrives for a general congregation meeting March 7. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Dolan arrives for a general congregation meeting March 7. (CNS/Paul Haring)

— Conventional wisdom has long held that the cardinals will never elect an American pope, lest the leadership of the church appear to be linked with the United States’ economic and geopolitical dominance. But the extroverted and jocular Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan, 63, charmed and impressed many in the College of Cardinals in February 2012 when he delivered the main presentation at a meeting Pope Benedict XVI had called to discuss the new evangelization. The pope himself praised the New York archbishop’s presentation on how to revive the faith in increasingly secular societies as “enthusiastic, joyful and profound.”

— Although not a familiar name in the press, Hungarian Cardinal Peter Erdo of Esztergom-Budapest, 60, is a major figure among his peers in Europe, the church’s traditional heartland and the region of more than half the cardinal electors. He was elected to a second five-year term as president of the Council of European Bishops’ Conferences in 2011.

Cardinal  Ouellet arrives for a general congregation meeting March 8. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Ouellet arrives for a general congregation meeting March 8. (CNS/Paul Haring)

— Canadian Cardinal Marc Ouellet, 68, is a member of the Society of St. Sulpice, whose members are, strictly speaking, diocesan priests but which is normally considered a religious order. Hence he is one of only 19 members of religious orders among the cardinal electors, who are overwhelmingly diocesan clergy. He is prefect of the Congregation for Bishops, which coordinates the nomination of bishops in Latin-rite dioceses around the world, so his work has brought him into frequent contact with most of his fellow cardinal-electors. As president of the Pontifical Commission for Latin America, he is well acquainted with one of the church’s largest and fastest-growing regions. The former archbishop of Quebec, who taught at the John Paul II Institute at Rome’s Pontifical Lateran University, is also a well-respected theologian.

— Italian Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi, 70, president of the Pontifical Council for Culture, was the prelate chosen by Pope Benedict to lead his 2013 Lenten retreat, which will make him a prominent voice at the Vatican in the run-up to the election. The cardinal, a scholar with little direct pastoral experience, has been leading the universal church’s efforts to develop a nonconfrontational dialogue with nonbelievers, trying to make Christianity intelligible to the modern mind and build a reason-based consensus on key moral issues.

Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga (CNS file/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Rodriguez Maradiaga (CNS file/Paul Haring)

— Another religious, a Salesian, Honduran Cardinal Oscar Rodriguez Maradiaga of Tegucigalpa, 70, is president of Caritas Internationalis, the umbrella group of national Catholic charities around the world. As a result, many of his peers have come to know the multilingual cardinal as the person spearheading assistance to the neediest of their people. He aroused controversy in 2002 with remarks about clergy sex abuse that struck some as overly defensive of accused priests and the church’s past policies. But he was already widely mentioned as a possible pope before the 2005 conclave that elected Pope Benedict.

— Argentine Cardinal Leonardo Sandri, 69, was born to parents of Italian descent and has maintained strong ties with both Italy and Argentina. As prefect of the Congregation for Eastern Churches, he is familiar with the challenges facing Eastern Catholics and the pastoral concerns of the church in the Middle East. He has worked in the Vatican for more than a dozen years, and previously served as nuncio to Venezuela and then Mexico. His only experience in a parish was a brief assignment shortly after his ordination as a priest.

Cardinal Sarah in a 2011 file photo. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Sarah  (CNS file/Paul Haring)

— Guinean Cardinal Robert Sarah, 67, is president of the Pontifical Council Cor Unum, which promotes Catholic charitable giving. He has used his leadership to emphasize Pope Benedict’s teaching that Catholic charitable activity must not be simple philanthropy, but an expression of faith, rooted in prayer and Catholic identity. A scripture scholar and former diocesan bishop, he served nine years as secretary of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples.

— Another leading voice of the South American church is 63-year-old Brazilian Cardinal Odilo Scherer of Sao Paulo, Brazil’s largest diocese. The son of German immigrants, he also has strong ties to Rome. He studied philosophy and theology at Rome’s Pontifical Brazilian College and Pontifical Gregorian University and worked as an official of the Congregation for Bishops from 1994 to 2001.

Cardinal Schonborn arrives for a general congregation meeting March 7. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Schonborn arrives for a general congregation meeting March 7. (CNS/Paul Haring)

— Austrian Cardinal Christoph Schonborn, 68, has known Pope Benedict for almost 40 years, having studied under him at the University of Regensburg, Germany. Even before his former professor became pope, the cardinal was well known at the Vatican and in wider church circles. He was invited in 1996 to preach Blessed John Paul II’s Lenten retreat and was the main editor of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, published in 1992. As the church in Austria has struggled with declining attendance and calls for change in some of its most basic disciplines, Cardinal Schonborn’s response has received increasing attention, with some praising his prudence and pastoral sensitivity, and others calling for more decisive action.

— Italian Cardinal Angelo Scola, 71, is the archbishop of Milan, the archdiocese led by both Popes Pius XI and Paul VI when they were elected. He previously served as patriarch of Venice, once the see of Blessed John XXIII. The cardinal, a respected academic theologian rather than a popular preacher, has longstanding ties to one of the new church movements, Communion and Liberation, which is based in his archdiocese.

Cardinal Tagle after being made a cardinal last November. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Cardinal Tagle after being made a cardinal last November. (CNS/Paul Haring)

— Philippine Cardinal Luis Tagle of Manila, 55, is one of the youngest and newest members of the College of Cardinals. Although he did not receive his red hat until November 2012, he had already made a name for himself at the world Synod of Bishops on the Word of God in 2008. This leader of one of the world’s fastest-growing churches is a popular speaker with a doctorate in systematic theology and has served on the International Theological Commission, an advisory body to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Cardinal Peter Turkson is the 64-year-old former archbishop of Cape Coast, Ghana, and current president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace. The cardinal, a biblical scholar who was active in ecumenical and interreligious dialogue, has frequently appeared on lists of possible popes. He aroused controversy in 2011 with a proposal for a “world central bank” to regulate the global financial industry, and then in October 2012 when he showed bishops at the Vatican a video warning about the growth of Muslim populations in Europe.

Cardinal Wuerl urges Catholics to pray for conclave

ROME (CNS) — At the March 10 Mass he celebrated at his titular church, the Basilica of San Pietro in Vincoli (St. Peter in Chains), Washington Cardinal Donald W. Wuerl urged members of the media  –a large part of the congregation — to get the word out about the importance of praying for the upcoming conclave.

Cardina Wuerl talks to reporters March 10 before Mass. (CNS photo/Robert Duncan)

Cardina Wuerl talks to reporters March 10 before Mass. (CNS photo/Robert Duncan)

“Your presence,” he told the camera crews and reporters, “makes it possible for everyone at home to join us in prayer.” He said the cardinal electors particularly need prayers to be sure “the Lord will work through each of us.”

“We need all the prayers we can receive,” he added.

He described the conclave as a “sacred moment for the church” continuing the papal line which goes back 2,000 years.

The cardinal said that because of the oaths the cardinals make, he could not say anything specific about the conclave, only to say it was starting March 12.

In his homily, he spoke of the importance of the sacrament of reconciliation, describing it as an opportunity to be “assured of God’s love and forgiveness.”

He urged those present to seek this sacrament particularly at this time in Lent as a “way to renew in our hearts” God’s forgiveness and experience the grace of God who “never, ever stops waiting for us.”

During Mass several tour groups and random tourists walked along the church’s perimeter to get a closer look of Michelangelo’s statue of Moses at the front right. They could only view it from the side during Mass as a guard kept them from getting a closer view near the altar. The statue, which dates from 1515, was originally intended as part of a 40-statue funeral monument for Pope Julius II.

In a reliquary under the main altar are the chains which give the basilica its name. According to tradition, these blackened chains held St. Peter when he was imprisoned in Rome and Jerusalem..

Cardinal Wuerl said the church, located near the Colosseum, is “very special” to him.

Although he celebrated the Mass in English, he gave remarks in Italian at the beginning and end of Mass and afterward greeted some of the Italians who seemed to know him well.

One couple teased him about the possibility that he might be pope and he politely urged them not to even joke about that.

Rome children give Cardinal George a conclave gift

Cardinal George receives a basked of hand-written prayers. (CNS/ Chris Warde-Jones)

Cardinal George receives a basket of hand-written prayers. (CNS/ Chris Warde-Jones)

ROME (CNS) — The children of the Church of St. Bartholomew on Tiber Island gave Cardinal Francis E. George of Chicago an icon of the Madonna and Child and asked him to take it with him into the conclave to elect a new pope.

As members of the College of Cardinals spread out over Rome March 10 to celebrate Mass in their titular churches, Cardinal George was at his, surrounded by children and teenagers who fill the little church each Sunday after religious education classes.

St. Bartholomew is not a parish church, but is used by the younger members of the lay Community of Sant’Egidio each Sunday for catechism classes and Mass, and most weekday evenings for vespers. The church also serves as an ecumenical shrine to 20th-century martyrs of communism, Nazism and Latin American dictatorships.

At the beginning of the Mass, Cardinal George told the congregation that the Christian life is full of choices, but it was God who chose them first. He asked for their prayers as he and the other cardinals prepare to meet to choose a new pope.The rector of the church, Father Angelo Romano, gave the homily during the Mass, which marked “Laetare” (Rejoice) Sunday, the midpoint of Lent. He told the children, their teachers and parents that the community rejoices because “Easter is near. But we have another reason to rejoice, too, because of the visit of His Eminence Cardinal George.”

Father Romano said it is an important time for the church; “we draw near to Cardinal George and all the cardinals with our prayers.”

After two children presented the cardinal with the icon, which is a small copy of a larger one found in the church, Cardinal George said, “I want to thank you for the present, and especially for your prayers for me and for all the cardinals. It’s an intense and very important moment for the church, so thank you for your prayers and for your faith.”

Before the Scripture readings were proclaimed, the children came up in procession and kissed the Book of the Gospels. They led much of the music with the beat of drums, guitar strums and rhythmic clapping.

Boston cardinal draws blockbuster crowd of fans to tiny church

ROME (CNS) — It took a “papabile” American cardinal as guest celebrant one Sunday to fill the pews of a small Roman church, which is normally trafficked only by hordes of backpack-slinging tourists.

Instead of dog-eared guidebooks in hand, people were actually looking for hymnals, extra copies of which had to be fetched from the sacristy by parish assistants.

The narrow church, which holds about 100 people, was packed standing-room only on the Fourth Sunday of Lent with both Italians and Americans, and dozens of journalists.

Cardinal Sean P. O’Malley of Boston visited his titular church of Santa Maria della Vittoria March 10 with the no-nonsense, businesslike air of a pastor who was there simply to preside over a liturgy.


U.S. Cardinal Sean P. O’Malley of Boston visits his titular church, Santa Maria della Vittoria, a tiny church more often teeming with tourists than parishioners. (CNS photo/Carol Glatz) (March 10, 2013)

Wearing his bright scarlet cardinal robes, he alighted from a dark sedan with Vatican City State license plates and strode straight up the steps: no waving or fanfare as he moved confidently through the crowd of cameramen.

Once inside, he put on his cornered-biretta hat and sprinkled holy water as he marched down the center aisle to the sacristy.

Little did he know that, while he was there to celebrate Mass for the local community, the people in the pews and the Discalced Carmelites who run the church were there to unabashedly cheer him on as the next pope.

“Eminence, we wish, and I say this with great hope, that this will be your last visit as titular cardinal,” Discalced Carmelite Father Stefano Guernelli, the church’s rector and former provincial superior, told the cardinal in his opening remarks.

He said they were praying for him to be the next pontiff, “however, without trying to push or overturn the Lord’s plans.”

“But you must promise that if our prayers are answered, your first visit as pope” will be back to “our church and yours, Santa Maria della Vittoria,” he said to rousing applause.

The priest said he had been telling journalists that “Cardinal Sean” is a “kind and friendly pastor, humble yet decisive in his actions because he truly loves the church.”

The only thing going against him “perhaps is that you are a friar and a Capuchin at that,” he said tongue-in-cheek, as the bearded Capuchin cardinal smiled.

Speaking with his deep, measured voice, Cardinal O’Malley said Mass and his homily in near perfect Italian, stumbling just a few times on the language’s tricky polysyllabic terms.


Cardinal O’Malley gave his homily in Italian. He asked for prayers the Holy Spirit would help the cardinal electors choose a pope “who will confirm us in the faith and do the utmost possible to make visible the love of the Good Shepherd.” (CNS photo/Carol Glatz) (March 10, 2013)

He began his homily thanking everyone for coming to pray “for our church in these days that are so important for us.”

Known for a sharp wit delivered with a poker face, the cardinal continued off-the-cuff, talking about the time he took possession of the Roman church in 2006 and teased the Carmelites that he was thinking of taking the church’s famed statue of St. Teresa of Avila, sculpted by Gian Lorenzo Bernini, back to Boston.

But he said the friars told him Napoleon had tried and, like the emperor, he, too, would fail.

“So it seems to me that (the friars) have never forgiven me” because the church rector wants him to become pope, the cardinal said.

“I want to assure him that after the conclave I will come back as your cardinal and perhaps I will take St. Teresa back to Boston,” he insisted with a wry smile.

He imperceptibly then switched gears to his serious side and gave a homily based on the day’s Gospel reading of the Prodigal Son, noting how many children of God today leave their father’s house — the church — because of “ignorance, a lack of feeling welcome, negative experiences, scandals, spiritual mediocrity” and other reasons.

Just like the father in Jesus’ parable, the church too must demonstrate a welcoming evangelical joy toward its lost sheep “without creating a difficult life toward those who have drifted and who ask to return.”

Because often they have suffered a lot after being far from God and they, like all people, are looking for real joy, the kind only God can give, he said.

Lent is the perfect time to return to one’s family “and feel that joy of being at home,” he said.

He ended his 13-minute homily by praying the Holy Spirit would help him and the other cardinal electors choose a new pope “who will confirm us in the faith, do the utmost possible to make visible the love of the Good Shepherd who goes looking for his lost sheep, to heal the sick and to embrace the prodigal son.”

Giulia Varrasso of Rome, who belongs to a nearby parish, said she had come to Santa Maria della Vittoria because she greatly admired the cardinal and wanted “to know him better.”

Cardinal O’Malley was her pick for pope, she said “because he’s a Franciscan” and she loves his humility, witty and laid-back style, and the religious order’s attention to the “weak and vulnerable.”

“I also like that he’s an American,” who can lead the Vatican out of its old ways of doing things and leave behind “the old mechanisms of power,” she said.

He also can renew the church “because he really understands these scandals” and has fought for more transparency, she said.

“I’m cheering for Cardinal Sean,” said Luigi Segoloni, who is originally from near Assisi, the home of St. Francis.

“We need fresh air, enough with these Italians and Europeans, for goodness sake,” said the Roman resident.

The U.S. cardinal is “very good, he made a very good impression with his homily; he has energy and he’s very fatherly,” said Segoloni.

Daughter of St. Paul Sister Germana Santos, who lived in Boston many years, praised the “very courageous measures” the cardinal took after he arrived at an archdiocese that was reeling from the spiritual and financial fallout of the sex abuse crisis.

“He sold all the prelates’ big residences and moved into the cathedral rectory” — a simple residence where he lived among his own priests “giving them an example of humility” and fraternity, she said.

An Italian woman, who asked her name not be used, said she wanted an American for pope.

Cardinal O’Malley “speaks from the heart.” While there are many good homilists out there, “you can feel his sincerity,” she said.

A conclave cardinal’s life by the clock

(CNS/Paul Haring)

(CNS/Paul Haring)

VATICAN CITY — Here is a translation of the College of Cardinals’ daily schedule for the conclave. All times are Central European Time with Eastern Daylight Time in parentheses.

March 12:

3:45 p.m. (10:45 a.m.) — Transfer from the Domus Sanctae Marthae to the Apostolic Palace.
4:30 p.m. (11:30 a.m.) — Procession from the Pauline Chapel to the Sistine Chapel.
4:45 p.m. (11:45 a.m.) — Oaths, meditation by Cardinal Prosper Grech, first ballot.
7:15 p.m. (2:15 p.m.) — Vespers in the Sistine Chapel.
7:30 p.m. (2:30 p.m.) — Transfer to the Domus Sanctae Marthae.
8 p.m. (3 p.m.) — Dinner.

March 13-15 or until election of a pope:

6:30-7:30 a.m. (1:30-2:30 a.m.) — Breakfast.
7:45 a.m. (2:45 a.m.) — Transfer to the Pauline Chapel.
8:15 a.m.-9:15 a.m. (3:15 a.m.-4:15 a.m.) — Mass in the Pauline Chapel.
9:30 a.m. (4:30 a.m.) — Prayer and two rounds of voting.
12:30 (7:30) — Transfer to the Domus Sanctae Marthae.
1 p.m. (8 a.m.) — Lunch.
4 p.m. (11 a.m.) — Transfer to the Apostolic Palace.
4:50 p.m. (11:50 a.m.) — Two more rounds of voting.
7:15 p.m. (2:15 p.m.) — Vespers in the Sistine Chapel.
7:30 p.m. (2:30 p.m.) — Transfer to the Domus Sanctae Marthae.
8 p.m. (3 p.m.) — Dinner.

Conclave smoke signal timetable

Vatican firefighters put the chimney in place this morning. (CNS/Paul Haring)

Vatican firefighters put the chimney in place this morning. (CNS/Paul Haring)

VATICAN CITY — For smoke watchers the world over, the cardinal electors were given the outline of their daily conclave schedules this morning.

Given their time for breakfast, Mass and lunch; time for a rest and a return to the Sistine Chapel, then the time for evening prayer and dinner, Jesuit Father Federico Lombardi, Vatican spokesman gave some broad indications on when to be in St. Peter’s Square to gaze at the chimney on roof of the Sistine Chapel or to watch on TV or the internet cameras fixed on the chimney.

The times below are listed in European Central Time. Remember, Europe — unlike the United States — does NOT go on Daylight Saving Time March 10.

When the balloting is unsuccessful — no candidate reaches the 2/3 votes needed for election — two votes are taken in the morning and two are taken in the afternoon. The two morning or two afternoon ballots are burned together, so there are only two smoke signals a day.

The first smoke signal can be expected about 7 p.m. Tuesday, after the first vote.

Beginning Wednesday, smoke would be expected at about noon and again about 7 p.m.

However, if a pope is elected on the first ballot of the morning, the white smoke would billow forth between 10:30 a.m. and 11 a.m. If he is elected on the first ballot of the afternoon, the white smoke would be seen between 5:30 p.m. and 6 p.m.

After a white smoke signal, it takes about 40-45 minutes before the announcement of the name of the candidate who won. He must accept the office, change to white vestments and the cardinals pledge their obedience and pray again.