Biden on Obama ticket: a Catholic with mixed record on church issues

Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois and Sen. Joe Biden of Delaware attend an AFL-CIO forum in Chicago Aug. 7. Obama, the Democratic presidential candidate, has chosen Biden as his vice presidential running mate. (CNS/Reuters)

Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois and Sen. Joe Biden of Delaware attend an AFL-CIO forum in Chicago Aug. 7. Obama, the Democratic presidential candidate, has chosen Biden as his vice presidential running mate. (CNS/Reuters)

WASHINGTON (CNS) — Delaware Sen. Joe Biden, announced Aug. 23 as Sen. Barack Obama’s choice as his running mate for the White House, puts on the Democratic ticket a Catholic who supports legal abortion but on other issues has been an ally for the church’s public policy interests.

Biden, 65, has come in for his share of conflicts with some in the church over his legislative support for keeping abortion legal. The National Right to Life Committee gives him a rating of 0 for his positions on select issues, including federal abortion funding and stem cell research as well as some relating to lobbying by groups like the National Right to Life Committee.

But he’s no darling of the “pro-choice” view, either, earning a score of 36 percent from NARAL Pro-Choice America for his votes on their select issues. Obama has a score of 100 percent from NARAL.

Biden has also talked frankly about the importance of his faith in his life, maintains close ties with his Catholic high school and isn’t hesitant to show off elements of his Catholic education in the Senate.

Biden was born in Scranton, Pa., to Joseph Biden and Catherine Finnegan Biden, both of Irish-Catholic background. When young Joe was 10, the family moved to Delaware, where his father was a car salesman.

He attended Archmere Academy, a Catholic prep school in Claymont, Del., but only after his mother told him he couldn’t go into the seminary, as he wanted, until after he had some experience dating girls, his mother told a reporter in 2007.

He has maintained ties with Archmere, which sought to name a new student center building for him in 2006. The plan was scrapped after Wilmington Bishop Michael A. Saltarelli opposed it, citing Biden’s votes on abortion.

The bishop cited a 2004 statement by the U.S. bishops about Catholics in political life, that says Catholic institutions “should not honor those who act in defiance of our fundamental moral principles.”

In a 2007 interview with the Christian Science Monitor, when he was a candidate for president himself, Biden said he grew up in the church at a time of great changes both in structure and in attitudes after the Second Vatican Council.

“I was raised at a time when the Catholic Church was fertile with new ideas and open discussion about some of the basic social teaching of the Catholic Church,” Biden told the Monitor. “Questioning was not criticized; it was encouraged.”

The newspaper quoted Biden’s recollection of a question to his ninth-grade theology class.

“How many of you questioned the doctrine of transubstantiation?” the teacher asked, referring to the teaching that the bread and wine change into the body and blood of Christ during Mass. No hands were raised. Finally, Biden raised his. “Well, we have one bright man, at least,” the teacher said.

Biden told the newspaper that the teacher didn’t say criticizing the church was good. “He led me to see that if you cannot defend your faith to reason, then you have a problem,” it quoted him as saying.

During the 1991 confirmation hearings for Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, Biden, then chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, was the one who engaged Thomas in sometimes lengthy discussions about natural law and its application to civil law. The church’s teachings about issues such as the right to life of all human beings are based natural law, the philosophy that individuals have certain basic human rights that are based on universal moral principles or on “a higher law” which is not limited by the letter of the law.

On issues including immigration, minimum wage, providing health care for all children and reinstating the assault weapons ban, his positions have been close to those of the church’s lobbying efforts. Biden voted to authorize the invasion of Iraq in 2002, but later became a critic of the war.

Chris Korzen, executive director of Catholics United, a nonpartisan organization that promotes the church’s social justice message in the political arena, called Biden’s selection a positive development.

He said Biden’s commitment to his Catholicism “has inspired his advocacy on issues such as genocide, universal health care, education, worker’s rights and violence against women.”

Korzen’s statement said he’s optimistic that Biden might “help move our nation beyond the divisive, acrimonious and unproductive debate” that has come to surround the issue of abortion. He noted that Biden has said he accepts the church’s teaching that human life begins at conception and said Biden has a hisotry of seeking practical ways of addressing abortion in ways that a broad spectrum of people can support.

Alexia Kelley, director of Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, said Biden’s “Catholic and working class roots have been a source of solidarity for him with hard-working American families who are suffering the most from the current economic crisis.”

Phil Lawler, editor of the Catholic World News Web site, said on a blog post the morning of the announcement that an Obama-Biden ticket might be helpful to the pro-life movement. “Any public discussion of (whether life begins at conception) can only help the pro-life cause, because the scientific facts are hard to deny,” Lawler wrote.

He said Biden’s choice also ensures a fresh debate on whether Catholic politicians who support legal abortion should be denied Communion. “On that issue, too, the discussion can only be helpful,” Lawler wrote, because of the “powerful witness” of bishops who would refuse the Eucharist to such politicians.

3 Responses

  1. I’m the legislative director for National Right to Life, and I have had interactions with Senator Biden on pro-life issues since as early as 1981. He is a strong supporter of the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade ruling, which mandated abortion on demand. He has played a leading role in blocking or trying to block the nominees to the Supreme Court who were opposed by pro-abortion advocacy groups, such as Robert Bork, Clarence Thomas, John Roberts, and Samuel Alito. Biden has not voted on the pro-life side on any roll call vote scored by National Right to Life since 2003.

    However, Biden’s record on certain pro-life issues is contrary to the positions that Obama has taken — which is to say, while Obama has always embraced the most expansively pro-abortion policy option of those placed before him, there are several specific issues on which Biden has not done that. These divergences actually illustrate some of the extremes of Obama’s record. For example:

    Obama vs. Biden on Partial-Birth Abortion

    The Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act was enacted in 2003, with Senator Biden’s support, and was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in April, 2007. (For more about the content and significance of this legislation, go here: http://www.nrlc.org/abortion/pba/PBAall110403.html)
    At that time, Barack Obama sharply criticized the U.S. Supreme Court for its ruling, saying, “I strongly disagree with today’s Supreme Court ruling . . .” As to Biden: “I voted for the partial-birth abortion ban,” said [Sen. Joe] Biden while answering a woman’s question at a conference sponsored by the National Jewish Democratic Council. “I think it’s an extraordinary circumstance, I make no apologies for it.” ABCNews.com, April 24, 2007.

    Obama vs. Biden on tax-funded abortions

    Barack Obama advocates federal funding of abortion, and while in the Illinois legislature he voted against legislation to restrict state funding of abortion on demand. That is consistent with the policy advocated in the proposed 2008 Democratic Party platform, which says, “The Democratic Party strongly and unequivocally supports Roe v. Wade and a woman’s right to choose a safe and legal abortion, regardless of ability to pay . . .” In short, Obama and the platform favor repeal of the Hyde Amendment and the other laws that prevent funding of abortion in federal programs such as Medicaid. But Senator Biden has been voting for many of those laws for decades. Biden has written, “I might also add that I find it difficult to understand how those who refuse to limit the right of abortion in this country can at the same time support the expansion of the government’s financial involvement in providing for abortions. That is why I have been a consistent supporter of the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits the use of Medicaid funds to finance abortions. I believe that it is not the government’s business to be promoting abortion in any way.” (Letter, June 16, 1983)

    Obama v. Biden on Born-Alive Infants Protection legislation

    On 2001, Biden voted for the language of the federal Born-Alive Infants Protection Act (BAIPA), which recognizes babies who are born alive during abortions as legally protected persons, while we recently released documents proving that Obama killed a virtually identical bill in the Illinois State Senate in 2003. For more information on Obama’s documented record on the live-born abortion survivors issue — as contrasted with his claims — go here:
    http://www.nrlc.org/ObamaBAIPA/Obamacoveruponbornalive.htm

    Douglas Johnson
    Legislative Director
    National Right to Life Committee
    202-626-8820
    Legfederal@aol.com

  2. I don’t pretend to have the direct experience of Mr. Johnson in working with Senator Joe Biden, but I do agree entirely that the Senator is a thorough disaster WRT Catholic issues which affect basic issues of human life and dignity. Although he isn’t the worst (Sen. Obama is closer to that distinction), he can in no way be counted as a supporter of Catholic moral principles on issues of human life and dignity. Even Ron Rosenbaum styles the decision to select him as VP “a huge mistake by Obama in choosing a self-important clown for vice president … Biden has proven himself incapable of opening his mouth without making you cringe at his self-congratulatory pretentiousness.” But then Sen. Obama supports the most savage policy towards the aborting of unborn human children, stem-cell research, and the death penalty. Can any Roman Catholic find a moral reason strong enough to force them to vote for such a candidate? [Please don't write the Iraq War. According to U.S. military sources the war will be brought to an end within a year no matter who is elected (Obama has said he would rely on U.S. military recommendations for any withdrawal). ]

  3. Is abortion stance the single issue on which you will decide who to vote for? Will you not consider other issues facing our nation, like the economy, Iraq, Russia/Georgia, affordable healthcare, corruption, the undue influence of lobbyists, etc.?

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 634 other followers

%d bloggers like this: